Should I Invest in Gold or Dollar?

Disclaimer: The owners of this website may be paid to recommend Goldco or other companies. The content of this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco & other reviews, may not be neutral or independent. We may receive a commission from the companies we recommend. The content of this site is informational in nature and should not be relied upon without consulting an investment professional.

Last Updated: May 17, 2024

With inflation rising and the stock market experiencing fluctuations, many people are considering their options for investing in the future. How can you safeguard your wealth and protect it against losses?

Some people invest in cash reserves, while others prefer gold investments. Which one is best for securing your financial future? There are pros and cons to each investment option. When investing in gold vs the dollar, which should you select? Keep reading to find out.

Key Takeaways

Pros of Investing in Gold

When safeguarding their retirement savings, investors know gold is often superior to investments tied to paper assets. While gold has always been a popular investment choice, the last twenty years have seen exponential growth among investors.

Gold Has a History of Long-Term Stability

Gold has been a currency for thousands of years, while paper currency has not existed as long. People seek ways to invest in assets that hold their value during economic turmoil.

Gold is considered a safe haven asset that typically holds its value or increases it during periods of stock market volatility. Precious metals are more stable than other volatile stocks tied to the stock market.

Top 3 Gold & Silver Companies in 2024

Best Overall
9.7

Bar Code Score Card ™

5/5
Goldco
Excellent customer service from precious metals experts.
Best For Service
9.4

Bar Code Score Card ™

5/5
American Hartford Gold
5 Star customer service, easy to work with, and a low price guarantee.
Best For Education
8.9

Bar Code Score Card ™

4.5/5
Augusta Precious Metals
Earned best overall gold IRA company of 2022 by Investopedia's most transparent.

Gold Is Not Tied to Fiat Currencies

Fiat currencies only retain their worth from the government. Unlike paper money, gold cannot be expanded to help central banks in times of struggle. Gold maintains its purchasing power, unlike fiat currencies that devalue over time.

Gold Offers Investment Portfolio Diversification

You should never put all of your investment funds into a single asset. Diversification is critical for protecting against catastrophic losses because of single financial events.

Buying gold and silver allows you to diversify your investment strategy and build a more varied investment portfolio. Diversification helps you mitigate and manage the risks of your investments.

Gold Investments Can Offer Tax Advantages

If you invest in gold as part of a precious metals IRA, you can take advantage of tax savings. Depending on the type of IRA, you can contribute or take a distribution without paying taxes.

Many options are available for those who want to invest in a precious metals IRA. You can purchase physical gold coins and bars, gold-focused mutual funds, gold stocks, and gold ETFs.

Work with a qualified financial expert to ensure you make focused decisions while investing in a gold IRA to follow the IRS rules and take advantage of the tax benefits.

Pros of Investing in Cash

Many people invest in cash assets. Saving cash allows you to prepare for the future in ways other investment assets cannot offer. Consider the pros of investing in the dollar below.

Cash Offers Liquidity

Cash offers a quick, easy, and accessible way to handle unexpected expenses. You will have access to the money you need if your roof springs a leak or your car breaks down. Selling other commodities takes time.  

Cash On-Hand Offers Investment Potential

During market downturns, people often hoard cash in their savings and money funds to weather the storm. Extra cash allows you to prepare to act when investment opportunities strike.

Cash Gives Investors Peace of Mind

Financial emergencies can arise without warning. Knowing you have available cash can remove worries about an uncertain tomorrow and give you great peace of mind.

What About the Cons of Investing in Gold Vs Dollars?

No investment is perfect, and there are always risks. Some investment assets are riskier than others. Which investment option is best? Weigh the cons of each below.

Cons of Investing in Gold

Many new gold investors may not realize the pros and cons of investing in gold. This precious metal offers more advantages than disadvantages, but you must know the pros and cons.

Periods of Poor Performance

No investment rises without experiencing poor performance at times. Gold is no exception. To combat the possibility of falling values, experts recommend investors dedicate no more than 5% to 10% of their investment portfolio to gold and other precious metals.

Making Decisions Based on Fear

One of the drawbacks of investing in gold is the fear factor. People often turn to gold during times of economic downturn, and panic drives their actions. Some unscrupulous gold dealers will prey on the fears of investors.

Always research carefully before investing in gold with any company. Read customer reviews, and choose a gold dealer with a proven track record of honesty and transparency.

Complex Investments

Those new to investing in gold may initially find the process overwhelming. You should first educate yourself before entering into any investment opportunity.

Cons of Investing in Cash

Investing in dollars has its drawbacks that cannot be ignored. Before you jump headfirst into holding cash, we recommend you survey the cons below.

Cash Performs Poorly

The dollar’s value drops quickly at times, and almost all investments outperform it. Gold outperforms all fiat currencies. In fact, when the dollar's value begins to fall, gold typically rises in value.

Cash Offers Lower Yields

The goal of any investment strategy is to obtain high yields. You want to get more than you put in. The purchasing power of cash degrades over time due to periods of high inflation or even deflation.

Cash typically offers lower yields than investment options like gold. Even high-yield savings accounts do not perform as well as gold investments in the long term.

Dollar Investments Bring Tax Implications

It is important to remember that the dividends earned from cash holdings are taxable income. The taxation could potentially reduce the return on your investment.

Investing in a gold IRA offers tax savings. ROTH and traditional IRAs offer tax advantages that can help you save for the future without the stress of paying taxes.

Cash Can Be Diverted from Your Bank Account

Many do not realize it is no longer their legal property once they place money into a bank account. All bank accounts are subject to IRS levies.

The bank can make you wait before allowing you to have access to your funds. Many feel unsafe putting cash into banks, even though they are FDIC-insured.

Investing in Gold Vs Cash: Which Is the Winner?

You have many options for investing your hard-earned money in the future. Retirement comes faster than most realize, and being prepared is critical.

Some people stuff cash in their mattresses or fill up a savings account, thinking that is the smartest and safest way to prepare for the future. Unfortunately, inflation comes along and makes the dollar devalue over time. You could be in for a rude awakening if you rely only on your cash reserves.

Gold is the clear winner when investing in gold vs dollar. Although investing in cash offers benefits, they cannot compare to those of gold investments.

Ways to Invest in Gold

You can invest in gold in four main ways, depending on your investment goals. Some people invest in gold for a rainy day, but most start around middle age as they become concerned about retirement. We will discuss the options below to give you a head start on your investment strategy.

Buy Physical Gold Bullion

Gold is a more accessible commodity to the average person than others. You can purchase physical gold bullion from pawn shops, online, and brick-and-mortar gold dealers, banks, and brokerage firms.

Bullion bars are a popular option because they easily stack and require no maintenance for storage. Investors also invest in gold coins. For liquidity purposes, most investors buy the most popular gold coins, such as the following:

You can also purchase gold jewelry as a physical gold asset, but this is not always the best option. The retail price of gold jewelry typically far exceeds the melt value of the pieces.

Before investing in jewelry, you need to know the purity level of the gold before you buy. Do not purchase jewelry for sentimental reasons because you can buy a piece for investment, only to find out it is worth very little.

Buy Gold Funds

If you are not interested in purchasing physical gold, there are other options like gold funds. Mutual funds and Exchange-Traded Funds are options for those who do not want the hassle of storing their physical precious metals.

Shares for these trade on the New York Stock Exchange. Each share of an ETF represents one-tenth of an ounce of gold. You can buy ETFs based on the price gold is trading at.

It is important to remember that gold shares are more volatile and can fall in value faster than physical gold bullion and coins. Gold funds present a greater risk but can be a part of a sound investment plan.

Buy Gold Futures

Gold futures are ideal for investors with more experience. These represent the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell gold at a specific price and for a specified time. You can buy or sell gold futures through the Chicago Mercantile Exchange.

Buy Gold Mining Stocks

You can also invest in gold mining stocks, though this presents a greater risk than physical gold bars and coins. Keep in mind that mining stocks can rise and fall without warning based on the actions of the mining company and its success. There is little security with this investment option because there is no physical gold to back up your investment.

How to Invest in a Gold IRA

Investing in a gold IRA is one of the easiest and most rewarding ways to invest in gold. There are only a few steps involved, including the following:

You will need to choose a self-directed IRA custodian to handle your account.

Next, you must select a precious metal dealer to help you purchase IRA-approved gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

You will need to choose an IRS-approved depository to store your precious metals. The IRS will not allow you to hold your IRA gold at home.

Your custodian and the dealer will work together to have your chosen gold delivered to your chosen depository for safe storage until you decide to take a distribution after you reach retirement age.

Consider Investing in Gold Over Cash

You now know gold is a more inviting investment option than dollars. If you want to take advantage of tax incentives, consider investing in a precious metal IRA. There are also other options, including ETFs, gold futures, and gold mining stocks.

There is excellent profit potential when investing in gold, though no investment is without risks. Gold is in limited quantities, making it a highly sought-after commodity, no matter how you invest.

Top Rated Gold & Silver Companies in 2024
Best Overall
9.7

Bar Code Score Card ™

5/5
Goldco
Excellent customer service from precious metals experts.
Best For Service
9.4

Bar Code Score Card ™

5/5
American Hartford Gold
5 Star customer service, easy to work with, and a low price guarantee.
Best For Education
8.9

Bar Code Score Card ™

4.5/5
Augusta Precious Metals
Earned best overall gold IRA company of 2022 by Investopedia's most transparent.
4
7.9

Bar Code Score Card ™

4/5
Birch Gold
High level of customer service and a solid reputation
5
7.0

Bar Code Score Card ™

4/5
Noble Gold
High level of customer service and a solid reputation